XML News Desk
Microsoft Pushes OOXML Over the Top
Microsoft Has Gotten Enough Votes to Make Its Open Office XML File Format (OOXML), the Default File Format in Office 2007
Apr. 7, 2008 03:45 PM
Digg This!
Microsoft has gotten enough votes to make its Open Office
XML file format (OOXML), the default file format in Office 2007, an ISO
standard, theoretically saving Office from being run out of town by a lot of
ODF-smitten government agencies.
There have been, as everyone must know by now, myriad
accusations of chicanery, undo pressure, committee-stacking, ballot
box-stuffing and other voting irregularities – on both sides of the aisle
actually – Microsoft points an accusing finger at IBM, an ODF supporter, as Sun
did during the aborted Java standards process for poisoning wells – and right
after the results were in CNET reported that the allegations roused the
European Commission – which, let’s face it, has what can only be described as a
hard on for Microsoft – to investigate.
It reportedly asked Norway
about any undue influence brought to bear after a Norwegian official Steve
Pepper claimed Norway’s
Yes vote should be thrown out as not representative of the majority opinion.
Seems the administrative group voted Aye although most of
the companies it represented said Nay. However, Standards Norway, the national
standards body, is hanging tough and not backing down.
Of course the EC, which openly favors ODF, is already
embarked on a major investigation of Office and OOXML and has already asked ISO
members whether Microsoft was using strong-arm tactics to get OOXML
standardized.
Because of these accusations Microsoft may still have to
survive any formal challenges made during the next two months.
Microsoft, in fact, is counting on it. Its director of
corporate standards, Jason Matusow, blogged that he expects IBM to instigate
them.
“We now see IBM/et al,” he wrote Wednesday, “driving an
orchestrated process attack in hopes of overturning the ratification of Open
XML, or at least to discredit what has come out of this long, global process.”
On the surface, at least, IBM VP Bob Sutor is taking the
high road and calling for reform of the standards process as well as
accommodation between ODF and OOXML.
Anyway, according to ISO’s official pronouncement Wednesday
OOXML wound up with 75% of the vote for and 14% against, a wider margin than
many expected.
However, there are many who will gag over ISO’s flat
assertion that the 3,500 comments raised as issues on the way to the weekend
vote were seriously addressed and resolved – even after they were whittled down
to 1,000. There simply wasn’t enough time. Heck, they had to bend the rules at
the Ballot Resolution Meeting last month because there wasn’t enough time to
deal with the thousand comments.
See this is the second time through – Microsoft lost the
first vote back in September – but according to ISO the issues were resolved
enough for places like Norway, South Korea, Ireland, the Czech Republic,
Denmark, the Philippines and South Korea to change their No votes to Yes as did
Finland, which previously abstained.
Cuba and Venezuela changed their Yes notes to No, and Kenya, which
previously voted Yes, abstained. New Zealand issued a statement
Sunday after the vote closed opposing Microsoft.
Germany
voted Yes again, India said
No again and Australia and Holland continued to
abstain.
The German and Polish votes may be dicey. At least that’s
what some claim.
OOXML was standardized by ECMA, which put it on the fast
track to ISO standardization in December of 2006.
ODF is the default format in OpenOffice and its spin-offs
like IBM’s Lotus Symphony and Sun’s StarOffice.
It was made an ISO standard in May of 2006 and OOXML
opponents argue that making OOXML a standard too would be one standard too
many. Of course ODF didn’t get OOXML’s kind of scrutiny and may not be able to
bear it.
Barring some upset, OOXML is now ISO/IEC 29500 as well as
ECMA standard 376 – or will be when it’s published and Lord knows how long that
will take. Further development will now move from ECMA to ISO. And it will
start with issues that surfaced during the voting process.
About Maureen O'GaraMaureen O'Gara is the Virtualization News Desk editor of SYS-CON Media. She is the publisher of famous "Billygrams" and the editor-in-chief of "Client/Server News" for more than a decade. One of the most respected technology reporters in the business, Maureen can be reached by email at maureen(at)sys-con.com or paperboy(at)g2news.com, and by phone at 516 759-7025.