XML News Desk
Brazil, India & Venezuela Join South Africa in Objecting to OOXML Standardization
Danish Open Source Business Association Has Protested the Danish Standard's "Yes" Vote for Standardization
Jun. 9, 2008 03:30 PM
At the eleventh hour Brazil,
India and Venezuela joined South Africa in appealing ISO’s
highly politicized standardization of Microsoft’s Office Open XML (OOXML) file
format.
Meanwhile, the Danish Open Source Business Association has
protested the Danish Standard’s “yes” vote for standardization claiming a lack
of consensus, rules violations, no final draft and little chance of
interoperability. It wants ISO to reopen the issue. Denmark’s is not a formal appeal
and Danish Standard disagrees with the charges made.
Microsoft declined to comment saying the flap is between ISO/IEC
and the national bodies.
ISO now has 30 days to sort out the appeals, with the count
starting June 2, and then if they meet the rules and compromise fails, it pass
them upstairs, so to speak, to the ISO Technical Standards Board and the IEC
Technical Management Board.
Brazil claims the hurried five-day ballot resolution meeting
(BRM) back in February was “inconclusive” and complains, like South Africa did,
that the text of the proposed final standard, which according to the rules
should be out, has been a no-show.
In its letter to ISO, Brazil says its delegation wasn’t
allowed to present “an important proposal regarding legacy binary mapping” at
the BRM for want of time despite protests by several delegations.
It says it “noticed that most of the decisions taken during
the BRM were based on the ‘lack of time’ argument, and we think that this is
completely incompatible with the kind of decisions that should have [been]
taken on that meeting.”
Brazil
said only 189 of the 1,027 responses attached to the OOXML draft specification
were aired – let alone resolved – for lack of time at the BRM, leading to a
blanket vote to accept the thing pretty as is and clean it up later.
Brazil
also remembers some decisions being taken “based on the argument that ‘we need
to give answers to journalists.’”
Brazil
alleges that the voting procedure at the meeting didn’t meet the rules. It says
a “default voting criteria” was used “because it was the ‘less bad’ criteria”
and did not meet the “intent of the vast majority of BRM delegates.”
“They went there,” it says, “to discuss the technical
propositions.”
Brazil,
however, seems to be suffering from a form of buyer’s remorse; despite whatever
mental reservation it may have had at the time, it did after all vote to accept
the voting procedure.
Microsoft said the week before last that Office 2007 SP2
would support the enemy OpenDocument Format apparently so it can say it
supports an ISO standard and not lose accounts. Microsoft isn’t planning to
fully support OOXML until Office 14, the next major release of Office.
About Maureen O'GaraMaureen O'Gara is the Virtualization News Desk editor of SYS-CON Media. She is the publisher of famous "Billygrams" and the editor-in-chief of "Client/Server News" for more than a decade. One of the most respected technology reporters in the business, Maureen can be reached by email at maureen(at)sys-con.com or paperboy(at)g2news.com, and by phone at 516 759-7025.